Skip to content

How to read your BFCM numbers in Shopify

Guides

By Colin Stuckenschneider, Founder, Configurate

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are the one week a year when your store gets more traffic than usual and customers arrive ready to buy. That makes it the best test your store will get all year. If something in your store slows customers down, BFCM shows it.

This guide walks through what to open in Shopify, what to compare it with, and the warning signs worth fixing before your next big sale.

Before you start: pick a fair comparison

A number on its own doesn't tell you much. Compare BFCM week (Black Friday through Cyber Monday) with two things:

  • The same days last year. Shopify Analytics lets you compare a date range with the previous year. If your BFCM dates moved, line up the days of the week, not the dates.
  • The week before the sale. This shows how the store performs with normal traffic, so you can see what the sale changed.

Write down anything that changed between the two periods: a new theme, new apps, a different discount, tracking changes or a big shift in ad spend. These explain a lot of "mystery" numbers.

Five numbers to check

1. Sessions and orders, side by side

In Shopify, open Analytics, then Reports. Look at sessions and orders for each period. If sessions went up a lot and orders went up a little, more customers came but fewer of them bought. That's the gap the rest of this guide helps you find.

2. Conversion rate by device

Open the sessions by device report and compare conversion on mobile and desktop. Most BFCM traffic is on phones. If mobile converts at less than half the desktop rate, the store is probably harder to buy from on a phone. Check the product page, variant picker, cart and checkout on your own phone.

3. Your top landing pages

Look at sessions by landing page. Your ads and emails sent customers to a handful of pages. For each of the top five, check how many visitors added to cart. A page with lots of sessions and few add-to-carts is the first place to look. It's often a slow page, a confusing offer or a sale price that doesn't show.

4. Where customers stopped

The conversion breakdown in Shopify Analytics shows how many sessions added to cart, reached checkout and completed checkout. Compare each step with last year:

  • Few add-to-carts: the product page isn't doing its job. Look at price, photos, variants, delivery dates and reviews.
  • Add-to-carts but few checkouts: something in the cart is in the way. Shipping costs, a discount that didn't apply or a slow cart drawer are common causes.
  • Checkouts but few orders: look at payment options, surprise shipping costs, or discount codes that don't combine.

5. Discounts and average order value

Open the sales by discount report. Check which codes and automatic discounts were used, and what your average order value was compared with last year. If a discount you planned barely shows up, customers may not have found it, or it may not have applied in checkout.

Five warning signs worth fixing

  1. Mobile converts far below desktop. The store works, but it's harder to buy on a phone.
  2. A top landing page with lots of traffic and few add-to-carts. Fix that page before you spend more on ads.
  3. Cart to checkout drop-off is worse than last year. Something changed in the cart, the shipping rules or the discount setup.
  4. Orders in Shopify don't match your ad platforms. If Meta or Google reported many more purchases than Shopify recorded, your tracking may be counting the same purchase twice.
  5. Pages felt slow during the sale. Test your top product page on mobile with PageSpeed Insights. Sale banners and app scripts added for BFCM often stay on afterward.

What to do next

Make a short list: what happened, the number that shows it, and the fix you'd try. Then start with the fix that affects the most customers, which is usually a mobile product page or the cart.

If you want help reading the numbers, the Shopify CRO Audit does this across your whole store: pages, tracking, apps, speed and product data. For a store-wide checklist, see the Shopify conversion audit checklist, and for ideas to make before next year, see 20 Shopify fixes to make before next BFCM.

Want a second pair of eyes on your numbers?

The Shopify CRO Audit turns what BFCM showed you into a ranked plan for the year, in 10–15 business days.

Surfaced by Configurate

Not ready for an audit? Get a free weekly report.

Every Monday, Surfaced turns your Google Analytics and Search Console data into a plain-English report: what changed, what to fix first and what AI assistants say about your store.

See what’s in the report

More guides

20 Shopify fixes to make before next BFCM

Twenty Shopify fixes for your next Black Friday and Cyber Monday, grouped by checkout, cart, product pages, mobile, promotions, speed and after the order.

Read the guide

Shopify search results get no clicks. What should you fix?

Find a search term customers skip, check what they see on your store and test one change. See how a camera shop helped customers find the right lens cap.

Read the guide

Free 20-minute call

Tell Colin what you’re seeing.

Share your store and what you’ve noticed. You’ll hear where he’d start and whether Configurate is the right fit.

Prefer email? Write to us at hello@configurate.com.