Shopify Conversion Audit Checklist: 12 Checks
By Colin Stuckenschneider, Founder, Configurate
You don’t need an agency to start a conversion audit. You need an afternoon, your phone and your Shopify admin. Run these 12 checks in order. The order matters: if your numbers are wrong, every later check is a guess.
Write down what you find as you go. One line per problem: the page, what happened and how you know.
Start with your numbers
1. Compare orders in Shopify and Google Analytics
Pick last week. Count orders in Shopify, then purchases in Google Analytics. A small gap is normal. A big gap means your tracking is broken, and that’s your first fix.
2. Write down where customers drop off
In Shopify Analytics, open the conversion funnel: sessions, added to cart, reached checkout, purchased. Note each number for mobile and desktop. These are your starting numbers. Every fix gets measured against them.
3. Split conversion by device
Compare your mobile and desktop conversion rates. Mobile is usually lower. If the gap is wide, start your review on a phone.
Check speed on a real phone
4. Open your top product page on mobile data
Turn off Wi-Fi. Open your best-selling product from an ad or a search result, the way a customer would. Count the seconds until you can tap the buy button. If it feels slow to you, it feels slow to them.
5. List every app that loads on product pages
Open your theme’s app embeds and your installed apps. Ask one question about each: does a customer need this on the product page? Chat, quizzes and pop-ups often load everywhere and help nowhere.
6. Look for leftovers from apps you removed
Uninstalled apps can leave code in your theme. Search your theme files for names of apps you no longer use. Leftover scripts slow every page.
Review how customers shop
7. Find a product without using search
Start on the homepage. Try to reach a specific product through the menu and collection filters. Count the taps. If you get lost in your own store, customers do too.
8. Read a product page like a stranger
Can you tell what it is, what it costs, which option to pick and when it arrives, without scrolling far? Check that every variant has its own image, and that sold-out options are clearly marked.
9. Answer the questions customers ask
Look at your last 20 support emails and reviews. If the same questions keep coming up, such as sizing, materials, shipping or returns, the answers belong on the product page.
Test cart and checkout
10. Add to cart and change your mind
Add a product. Change the quantity. Remove it. Add a discount code. Each step should work on the first try, on a phone. Note anything that jumps, reloads or surprises you.
11. Place a real order
Buy something from your own store on your phone. Watch for surprise shipping costs, forced account creation and payment options that don’t show up. Check that Shop Pay and your other express options appear.
12. Check what happens after the order
Read the confirmation page and email. Then check that the order shows up once, and only once, in Google Analytics and your ad platforms.
Rank what you found
A list of problems isn’t a plan. Score each one three ways:
- Impact. How many customers hit this, and how close are they to buying?
- Effort. A settings change, a day of theme work or a bigger project?
- Risk. Could the fix break something else?
Fix the high-impact, low-effort, low-risk problems first. Then measure against the numbers you wrote down in check 2. Give each change two to four weeks before you judge it.
What this checklist can’t tell you
You can run every check here without touching code. Some causes sit deeper: which script slows the page, why two reports disagree, how your product data limits your filters. That work needs someone in your theme and your analytics.
That’s what our Shopify CRO Audit covers. To see what an audit should include at each price, read what a Shopify CRO audit includes and costs. If you’re getting visits but few orders, start with what to check first.
Want it done for you?
The Shopify CRO Audit runs every check here, and the ones that need code access. $2,899, fixed, in 15 business days. You get a ranked 30–90 day plan your team or ours can build.
Not ready for an audit? Get a free weekly report.
Every Monday, Surfaced turns your Google Analytics and Search Console data into a plain-English report: what changed, what to fix first and how to get AI assistants to recommend your store.