Case Study - Alder Ferry’s coffee subscriptions
We put one-time and subscription prices side by side and showed the next charge date in the cart.
- Client
- Alder Ferry Coffee
- Project date
- Service
- Shopify subscription design and conversion analysis

At a glance
About Alder Ferry Coffee
Alder Ferry Coffee sells its Morning Crossing coffee as a single bag or on repeat delivery every four weeks. Customers choose a grind for their brewer, from whole bean to drip machine or French press.
- Industry
- Coffee
- Key results
- First-order conversion up 25%, subscription adoption up 35% and 80 more subscribers reaching a second bag
The challenge
Two decisions stood between customers and their first bag
Customers choosing their first bag of Morning Crossing need to know which grind works with their brewer and what the lower subscription price commits them to.
The one-time price was harder to find
The original product page led with the $16.20 subscription price. Customers who wanted one bag had to open a menu to find the $18 price.
The cart omitted the delivery schedule
Customers who picked repeat delivery could see what they owed for the first bag. The cart gave them no date for the next charge.
The solution
Subscription and one-time prices customers can compare before checkout
We organized the grind picker by brewer, put both prices together on the product page and carried the repeat-delivery schedule into the cart.
A grind picker organized by brewer
We labeled options by brewing method and displayed the corresponding grind below. Customers can select French press and see that they’ll get a coarse grind.

One-time and repeat-delivery prices side by side
We made the $18 single bag the default. The repeat-delivery option shows the 10% savings, the $16.20 price per bag and the four-week delivery schedule. That answers two questions from our Shopify conversion audit checklist: what it costs and which option to pick.

The next charge date in the cart
We added the next charge date and amount to the cart for repeat orders. Customers can use the edit link next to the coffee to switch to a single bag before checkout.

The results
25% higher first-order conversion and 80 more subscribers reaching a second bag
First-order conversion rose from 3.2% in the original flow to 4% in the redesigned flow. More customers chose repeat delivery on their first order and came back for a second bag.
| Metric | Original flow | Redesigned flow | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-order conversion rate | 3.2% | 4% | +25% |
| Visitors placing a first order | 800 | 1,000 | +200 orders |
| First orders on repeat delivery | 160 | 270 | +68.8% |
| Subscription adoption rate | 20% | 27% | +35% |
| Subscribers reaching a second bag | 96 | 176 | +83.3% |
| Second-bag retention rate | 60% | 65% | +8.3% |
Your store
Selling subscriptions on Shopify?
Ongoing Shopify CRO runs in fixed-price, 2-week sprints, from $3,500. Colin finds where first-time customers hesitate, builds the fix and measures it against your starting numbers.